Season Pennant and Commissioners’ Trophy Winners
- The Hot Sundae Pennant is awarded to the team with the best season record.
- The Hot Sundae Commissioners’ Trophy is awarded to the season’s playoff winner.
2023
- Hot Sundae Commissioners’ Trophy – The Dovercourt Deep Cuts
- Hot Sundae Pennant – The Dovercourt Deep Cuts
2022
- Hot Sundae Commissioners’ Trophy – The Dinglers
- Hot Sundae Pennant – The Dinglers
2019
- Hot Sundae Commissioners’ Trophy – The Whitney Houston Astros
- Hot Sundae Pennant – The Whitney Houston Astros
2018
- Hot Sundae Commissioners’ Trophy – The Dinglers
- Hot Sundae Pennant – The Dinglers
2017
- Hot Sundae Commissioners’ Trophy – Debasers
- Hot Sundae Pennant – The 2012 Champions
2016
- Hot Sundae Commissioners’ Trophy – Debasers
- Hot Sundae Pennant – The 2012 Champions
2015
- Hot Sundae Commissioners’ Trophy – Debasers
- Hot Sundae Pennant – Debasers
2014
- Hot Sundae Commissioners’ Trophy – Debasers
- Hot Sundae Pennant – The Whitney Houston Astros
2013
- Hot Sundae Commissioners’ Trophy – The Whitney Houston Astros
- Hot Sundae Pennant – The Whitney Houston Astros
2012
- Hot Sundae Commissioners’ Trophy – The Whitney Houston Astros
- Hot Sundae Pennant – The Dinglers